No Wine Over $20-Reviews and the LA Wine Scene

Pardon my indulgence here, as we add another zero to Wines Under $20. But man, what a night . . . John Caplan, owner of Grapes Wine in Norwalk, CT., ushered in my 50th birthday with an assortment of wine that defied generosity. He's got a great palate, his store gets wines that others don't, and here we go!

Wine One!
2001 Frederick Magnien Charmes-Chambertin~$150: Actually, this was my sole contribution to the evening. An average vintage grand cru from an above average producer. This was earthy yet soft, with unleashed cherries running from barn to barn. This came from a ridiculous case discount some years back from North Berkeley Wines. [ed. I am dropping all wine clubs - except Tablas Creek - and joining NBW's Club Beaune. Serious.]. There are better burgs, but this showed very well. A fine way to start the proceedings. Two Mice.

Wine Two!!
1998 E. Pira Barolo Cannubi: This is where things started to get silly, in a hurry. In the traditional style, this nebbiolo showed its perfume and elegance in a way that shows Robert Parker is often nuts. One, and I'll argue this til the cows come in, Barolo is NOT the "road tar, stern, leather, tobacco ... massive" wine that RP claims. Maybe the crappy ones, but not this violet-trimmed, spicy pecan pie, eurphoric glass of sap from some exotic tree that hasn't been discovered in a Brazilian forest. It blew me away, but it was not BIG. It was the high school girl that no one noticed until the 10th year reunion. And, RP gives it a '91'. I mean, what does a number even mean? He gives dozens of California chardonnays the same number. It's just nuts. Who would opt for a Neyers Vineyard chard over this? Perhaps the blogmeister's wife (yes, Dotoré, I read your lovely comments). But hey now, this is what Barolo's all about. Of course, you have to try about 10 to get one, and it makes Burg hunting look easy. Two and half MICE. [ed. tour de force review of two BIG problems and one teeny weeny one. RP's ratings are absurd. The 100 point system is more like 12 points - 85 to 97. Barolo is so challenging that it DOES make Burgundy look easy. You DO have to go through 10 to find 1 that is more magical than Siegfried and Roy. OK. Bad metaphor. We all look to Dotoré for leadership in dealing with that itty bitty problem.]

Wine Three!!!
2003 La Cueva del Contador Rioja $75 online: At this point John pointed to his lofty rack and asked in his South African lilt what I wanted. Not ever having tasted a high-end tempranillo, I requested a Rioja and got this . . . words, words, words. OK, here's a try. The first sip was ordinary. I didn't get it. Then, Kaiser Soze [ed. the sneaky chameleon character from Usual Suspects], highly metaphorical! entered the room. The second and subsequent sips filled my senses with an ethereal implosion that said, "You've never had anything like this, and you won't ever again". A wine for the ages. Descriptors don't help, but people talk about the mid-palate and this Rioja hit this landing strip like a cyclone. Three MICE. Only 200 bottles exported to USA, and John, Big Gary My Driver, and I couldn't finish because here came...

Wine Four!!!
2003 Michele Castellani Amarone I Castei~$80 online: OK, this wasn't the best Amarone I've had, but that's only because a few years back John poured me the '97 Quintarelli, which deserves a four-page entry in Wikipedia. But this was pretty special. The Blogmeister says he doesn't favor Amarone, and we're gonna have to remedy this in July. I'd only say this: it is a hard to match with food. I'd pick some hard cheese and call it a day. This is, like all great wines, bursting with a myriad of flavor yet NOT HEAVY. You can taste the winemaker's pride, because he knows no one is making anything else like it outside of Veneto. To freaking die for. Three MICE.

Wine Five!!!!!
2003 Chiaccheri Amarone: Three More Mice. Once you've gone with Amarone, you cannot return to anything else. Your palate would laugh at you. I'm running out of mice, but this was my favorite of the night, a little richer and more chocolaty than the previous bottle, which Big Gary preferred. But he preferred this, too. I wanted to smack myself so I could drink more, but I only managed a glass and half. Spent, spoiled and saturated, we returned home. A night for the ages.

[ed. Well, I am spent. Reading this review was a bit like watching James Brown - hit me!! - try to totter off stage under a sweat soaked cape only to toss it off and rush back to the mike screaming more ecstasy into the crowd. Again and again. The natural response is to wish I was there. Perfectly normal. Just because I have never tasted an Amarone I liked much less loved. Same goes for Tempranillo. In fact I was recently disappointed in a 1996 Alenza - to be reviewed in next week's post - and a 1994 Roda I that should have been ethereal instead of OK and quickly fading. Good news is we get Mouse in a couple weeks. Our plan is forming like a Bush White House memo finding a way to bomb another Middle East country. Secretly, demented, grandiose. If only we can solve that little teensy problem...Happy 50th mister!] Share your all-time greatest wine? I already did in this post from August 2007.

Ladies and Genulmens here he is the Hardest Workin Man in Show Biznisss...that's ten mouses!!!!!!!!!!

It is the plain trooth. A golfer recently told me "Costco has the best wine selection in the country". All things considered - golfers know putters, not wine - it is hard to challenge this observation.

Take Bob Seger and Bruce Springsteen. In a recent Vanity Fair article Bob Dylan says "many folks think Seger is the poor man's Springsteen. I say Springsteen is the rich man's Seger". [ed. Sounds more authentic if you hold your nose while speaking.] Costco is no Hi Time but then Springsteen sold many more albums than Detroit's favorite son (along with the Ig as in Iggy Pop and Alice Cooper). Dylan settles things by admitting "I love them both".

The point is that you can't go wrong with Springsteen and that is how folks today think of Costco's wine selection. But if you want to "take a little trip" with wine then you have to find the Hi Time in your neighborhood. Or listen closely over and over to Hollywood Nights and Night Moves if you want to catch the rarified discriminating vibe.

"Workin' on mysteries without any clues". This is the point isn't it? You can always find a Springsteen CD in a SecondSpin bin but finding vintage Seger is a bit tougher.

What does that have to with wine? Dotoré has earned the respect of his family and friends as a wine snob such that he is tasked with finding the right wines (this always means U20s) for a Kansas City wedding. A quick run through the KC Internet directory of fine wine stores pulled up some home pages more suited to the wine department at Ross Dress for Less. The go-to store in KC is a liquor store that you can be sure is the name that falls off the tip of everyone's tongue when asked who has the best wine store in town. Like Brooosss the Boss. Not an inspiring selection but hard to argue against given the widespread belief.

In fact the local KC liquor emporium did not list any French wines. Or Italians or Spanish. Argentina? Let me be Frank. Shirley you're kidding. We did find a party planner with a palate who probably has a tiny local following of wannabe but tooscaredtabe polygamists. At least she had a decent wine list that didn't look like a BevMo 2-for-1 clearance. Then it hit me. Kirkland. Buy the freaking wine at Costco, Dotoré. I hope people don't have some kind of misplaced attitude about Costco being low class. As Beastie Boys Mike D once said..."let me clear my throat".

Back to the trooth. The new wine buyer at Costco has a more adventurous palate than the former gal. I see all kinds of wines in the Costco bins that look interesting to me. Along with the usual uninteresting retread Napa trophies (BV & Silverado), Aussie Syrahs (oh, I mean shiraz) I saw a Kiwi white (but no pinot...of course we aren't really sure there are any worth buying), some interesting Rhones from the 2005 vintage, a Spanish Grenache Rosé ($24, however, is not competitive in this sector), and two Argentina Malbecs from the right regions...and at the right prices. There are even more online.

2005 Fabre Montmayou Malbec Gran Reserva $18: A bargain steal go-get-some Gold Medal winner in a nationwide Malbec competition. This is a great example of how Costco is moving to the head of the U20 class. Elegant and high-toned. What does that mean? It means the wine holds together well. The flavors are not too extreme, the tannins actually contribute to the flavor profile without overwhelming, the weight is just right neither heavy and overbearing or porous like tissue. Here is somebody else's review (why not?).

A magnificent Malbec! It picked up a trophy at the inaugural Wines of Argentina Awards held in Mendoza in 2007, having wowed the international panel of judges - included among them wine expert Jancis Robinson, who gave it an impressive 17 out of 20.

This mulberry and spice-flavoured red wine was made by Hervé Fabre, who was originally involved in the Bordeaux wine trade, before he and his wife fell in love with Argentina and moved there to establish a boutique winery. Hervé's experience in producing top quality wines shines through in this tremendously rich, silky-smooth wine.

Ripe blackberry and bramble aromas merge seamlessly with spicy oak and vanilla flavours. Full bodied, yet seriously smooth and warming. This 89 Parker point wine is sure to survive for many years to come. Definitely a wine to enjoy with fine food ... try it with rare roast beef or a juicy steak.

2006 Preludio Malbec $12: This is one Tempus Alba wine we did not taste when we visited this past March [ed. tBoW coverage here]. Of course, as the self-described big boutique (350,000 cases) there is enough of this to be handled by the Kirkland Nation. Aromatic nose. Syrupy. A bit thick. Very Rollandian even though I do not think he consults here. Doesn't that say it all? Fruity, forward, some tannins. Looking to go over the top like Reggie Bush on the goal line. Maipu fruit which is a good thing. Check out the embossed label. All Tempus Alba labels seem expensively embossed like this. 13.9%

2001 Mouliniere Les Sigillaires St. Chinian $9: Picked from the wall of bargains at Woodland Hills Wine Company. At 7 years this wine has to be peaking if not even entering a long snooze. St. Chinian is one of the longer lived appelations in Languedoc. Most likely a Syrah and Grenache blend. Very nice if soft out of the bottle. Tannins have slipped out the back door. This wine is ready as Norma Desmond for her next blockbuster. Unlike the femme fatale of another era this St. Chinian is simply happy to have one last shot at applause. It gets mine.

Veramar Vineyards Rooster Red $17: Jim Bogaty of Veramar VIneyards in Virgina's beautiful Shenandoah Valley tips his hat to good old fashioned Dago Red [ed. PC apologies to those offended by tBoW's use of a crude name for fine old world style wine.]. If only those old style wines were this good. Rooster Red is one of those unusual and pleasant Proustian experiences. As I drink this little gem I vaguely recall every Italian table red I ever tasted...except this one is much better than any of the others ever were. Sweeti-ish, balanced, Chianti-style. Excellent job!

Here is possibly the rocking-est song every recorded - smoke, trip lights, long hair, leather everywhere. After this photo of tBoW with Allison and Maya of the rocking-est girl band to ever bash a guitar and drums (respectively), the Donnas. [ed. This post really slid into a musical maelstrom. It can happen. What next? Betty Page?]

Tension builds as we await hot summer nights in Los Angeles that go so well with BBQs, lounging outside, dinner with friends and all kinds of wines. You can tell folks are getting restless when Memorial Day arrives with a full dinner party calendar. We attended two and, what a surprise, wine was the theme. One was a little more structured featuring Argentina wines and wine glasses with the tBoW URL!!!and our host's names in larger script - go figure. The second was more informal meandering through a cellar that needs purging. tBoW was careful to take notes for your information.

2007 Bartenura Moscato d'Asti $9: Summertime is for drinking Moscato d'Asti, the slightly sprtizy Itlaian wine that tastes like peaches and feels like 7-Up! This was bought at Costco. Another testament to the wine buyer there. I can only recall dreaming of the day any Moscato d'Asti might be in a Costco bin. Pinch me. It was so worth the $9 tag. Prices for these wines have crawled higher in recent years so this is quite the bargain. Forget the tasting terms dictionary and the wine wheel. This is purr-fekt for that hot evening outdoors. Brilliant blue bottle. Oy! It's kosher too. In case you did not already know..the alcohol on these wines are traditionally "lower"...like 5.5%!! We are not missing the "1".

2007 Montes Cherub Rosé of Syrah $12: Chilean "double gold winner" at San Francisco wine competition. One of those wines people buy because they like the label with the plump cherub. Imagine posting a bacchinalian chubby image as your symbol. Lovely ruby red. Syrahs tend to produce darker tones in pinkies. I prefer Syrah rosé and this is good enough but not my favorite. A bit grassy on the nose. Strawberry flavors. Would like more acid and more fruit. Applaud the screw top! 13.6%

2006 Les Aphillanthes Cotes du Rhone $10: Lacking in fruit, good acid, short finish. This wine tasted better with the cheese plate. I preferred it to the Montes. Nice enough but I am confident we can do better. Purchased at Hi Time. 13%

2004 Carinae Malbec Reserva $14: Purchased at The Wine Country. Briny, meaty nose. Not like many of the fruity and forward Malbec wines. Vanilla, baking soda, pumpkin bread. More mature in style. Maipu juice.

2004 Altocedro La Consulta Reserva $13: Costco purchase. From Valle de Uco, La Consula vineyard at 5,000 feet. High toned, creamy, tannic. Mocha powder (it's the tannins). Muted nose. Dark berry fruit. Taste the alcohol. Opened up nicely over an hour. Impressed the missus. Cannot beat the value. Will keep a couple years. Testimony to the palate of the new Costco wine buyer. 14.6%

1996 Condado de Haza Alenza $60 online: In the cellar since release close to a decade. Premium picked Tempranillo from Alejandro Fernandez's best Ribera del Duero estate. 2,000 cases aged 30 months in new American oak. We exoected it to be the best wine this evening. Shoe polish nose signals bretanomyces. Red brick color. Clear. Deep, mature, very nice. Balanced, gentle. Red berry fruit. Excellent. Somewhat surprising that 30 minutes later the fruit is gone. Drink up and be quick about it. 13%

1996 Justin Cabernet Franc $150 from the winery: When have you seen this wine? Fuggidaboudid. If you see it you have to open it...with some trepidation. The owner said he received it recently in a library release through Justin's wine club. Lively nose. Fresh fruit although somewhat muted. Flavors are very good. Blueberries. Soft and balanced. Tannin-free. The wine shows its age but it is holding up nicely. 30 minutes it remains drinkable. Justin makes the best cab in Paso which is a bit like Sid Vicious singing Sinatra. Or building the best boats in Death Valley. Mangled metaphors aside, this wine was pretty nice...and damned surprising. 14.1%

Hey!! Here's Sid now!!!

Call me a snob. I think the best dining on the West Coast is in San Francisco (notable exception Bashan in Montrose, Lou in Hollywood). In LA fine dining is first and foremost measured by how costly is the dinner (lower cost = worse fare). I also believe that fine dining in LA invariably comes in two flavors: Italian or the mega-steak house. Given a choice I will take Italian any day over the Mortons and Mastros gang (especially local fare like Giovanni in Woodland Hills). Today's steakhouses are modern day cafeterias. They all serve the same stuff essentially the same way. Given a choice I will take LA's international choices (Chinese in Monterey Park, Mexican - Tamayo - in East LA, Korean in mid-Wilshire, D' Cache - Argentine - in Burbank) every time over asparagus, spuds with lobster and a New York I can burn myself on my home grill. [ed. Dined at Cube in West Hollywood and found it very Frisco-like in an LA way so things are looking up around here...now if could just convince restaurateurs to serve something other than Cabernet and Chardonnay...some are, some are...but not enough!]

And Baghdad by the Bay? You can begin with wine lists at so many of the City's restaurants. They blow our predictable burg away. tBoW has covered this angle before. If you want to push in my big snobby nose on this subject just click here and read this column and show me something, anything comparable to a Beaujolais Cru celebratory list from LA.

I just want to make it clear why I am so excited that a top notch, inventive, comfortable dining establishment with an enchanting wine program is within driving distance of my hood. The place is called Palate and it is in Glendale [ed. back entrance to the wine store pictured] down the street from the "architectural steakhouse", the new Americana mall.

The chef at Palate is Octavio Becerra who worked side-by-side with Joachim Splichal. That's the foodie story. But what about the wine? We have Sommelier Steve Goldun who was singled out on this blog when he was tBoW's unofficial wine guru. Steve knows wine. And, best of all, I learned long ago when he was prowling the aisles at Woodland Hills Wine Co. that my palate matches well with his.

It has long been the that, as a consumer, you will enjoy wine that much more if you can find a decent store with great selection and fair prices. But you may consider yourself very lucky if you can find someone on the floor who knows your palate and would never put anything in your hands that would not slide over your tongue, slip down your gullet and bring a smile to your lips. Enter Steve Goldun.

Steve knows value...loves Burgundy...and sells wine out of the retail space in the large and roomy tasting bar, shop and party area. I don't know whether to yell or wet myself. [ed. tip - let Steve choose your wines].

We took a bunch of photos of the place. The wine reviews are compiled from two dinners a week or so apart.

2007 Nicolas Reverdy Sancerre Rosé <$20: Pinot noir fruit, extra dry, 12%. Dry dry dry. Tons of acid and just enough fruit to keep me from whistling involuntarily. I like it. My dining pal don't. Here is a fun link about the winery and owners.

2007 La Spinetta Moscato d'Asti Biancospina $16: "He bottles this every 60 days". And it tastes that fresh. I love Moscato in the summer! Of course he carries it. It is like buttah, ice cream. So fresh and fruity and spritzy. Mind you, we are not asking. Steve just KNOWS what should be had next. 5.5%

2004 Dirler Sylvaner Vielle Vignes $20: Stony, bitter, bright. Classic Alsatian, a region that makes wines in a style I do not especially favor. However, we cannot deny this wine is very well made and absolutely terroir driven. One more sign of the ban on Stepford Wines on Steve Goldun's list.

2002 Domaine Huet Vouvray Sec Brut Petillant $24: Here is the sommelier's skill. Joe Dressner says one should avoid sparkling wine from Vouvray altogether [ed. click here to learn where is Vouvray]. Well Mr. Dressner may be right about alot but he is wrong about Vouvray sparklers when it comes to this wine. This is delicious. Yeasty like a fine champagne. Golden orange color. Lemon fruit, minerals, long toasty finish. What a great bottle of wine. Chenin Blanc - world's most underrated varietal? [ed. couple months ago you would have shouted Torrontes] Spectacular. I ordered it right away to kick off the second evening dinner. Robert Chadderton selection.

2006 Domaine Huet Haut-Lieu Sec Vouvray $20: The non sparkling version. Super clean nose, actually a very faint whiff of bleach. Now that is aerifaction. Serve cold and it can cleanse a palate between courses. Went great with the salmon rillete (in mason jar). The Wine Doctor has an excellent post on the wines from Huet including these two. 13%

Alina (near-perfect waiter) suggested a sampler of cheese, crostini, salumi and the duck pate. We also had an assortment of green and brown olives. Loved it all. But my dining pal and I practically fell out of chairs and went hand-to-hand over the little cup of balsamic sauce. The consistency and appearance of apple butter but the flavor of fine balsamic. Tasted good on everything. Even plain off the knife!!

2006 Fiorini Lambrusco Grasparosso di Castelvetro $12: Suggested by our near perfect Alina who otherwise was on the money with every other tout. Lambrusco is red, not even close to pink, and frothy as in frizzante. Must be an acquired taste because neither of us liked it. Now she did recommend it with the duck pate stored in teeny mason jars. And it did work with that but...nah.

We did have a couple of reds for dinner #2 that must be mentioned.

2006 Trenel Cote du Py Morgon $20: Served with the pickled cherries which was purr-fick. Some tannins, rich flavors. IGTY liked it a lot. I brought up the point that since IGTY loves William Selyem it figures he would like the 2005/06 Beaujolais wines. He gets his red wines from the local purveyor who specializes in Santa Barbara and Paso products which are actually too overblown for my taste (Tablas Creek the exception). Of course, this is just part of my plan to get him to bust out more of his W/S wines stored in my cellar. The Trenel wines from both vintages are truly wonderful. Reviewed in other tBoW posts [ed. June 30 07, October 1 07, January 5 08, and April 12 08] and still worth searching out. 13%

2003 Redortier Gigondas $30: This knocked everyone off their seats. Half Grenache, half Syrah; a very good blend as a rule. Pays off here. Smoky and fruity, dark dark cherries and chocolate. Transcendent. We took a few home with us. Another Chadderton selection. 13%

The lesson is if you want something very close to the flavors of Burgundy with all the finesse and one quarter the cost look to the south and seek out the Beaujolais Cru wines.

1998 Lopez de Heredia Vina Gravonia Blanco $34: A risky wine and a find at ten years. Nose and flavors are chalky, reserved, dry, not much acid left. I have never been a fan of Spanish white wines. Unless they are from the Basque country which of course Steve has in the store. I purchased a white and pink Basque wine but did not finish my pour of Gravonia. My dining pal (DP) liked it. 12%

2002 Javillier-Guyot Savigny les Beaune Blanc $34: I know this was the wine of the evening because it still lit me up after the first four tastes. Stewed or sauteed apples. Pippin apples when you break them open and stick your nose in there says DP. This French chardonnay can never be mistaken for a new world wine. It is never even close. This is toasty in flavor, golden in color. Not tasting the butterscotch...yet. Could get there. But I would drink it now. Great depth of fruit. Mmm-mmm.

Served with the canneloni in fresh tomato sauce that was closer to finely chopped salsa than sauce. Tomatoes worked with the White Burg. Also gnocchi with green peas and morels. A very earthy dish that complemented the toastiness.

Try wait. One more wine.

2006 Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls Blanc $30: Normally I would say absolutely no to a fortified wine after the parade that came across our table. But that would be like saying no to golf lessons from Phil "the thrill" Mickelson. Or poker lessons from Daniel Negranu. Or Jennifer Tilly.
This pale salmon Provencal wine was so distinctive. Briny nose even in the first taste. Then honey and fruit, oatmeal with brown sugar. On the second evening it was all mocha and coffee, caramel and apples. Made from three different grapes. 25 % "Muscat d'Alexandrie", 70% "Grenache blanc", 5% "Malvoisie (Tourbat)". Here is the link to the label. Charming. Not everyone liked it as much. 16.5%.

We took a 40 minute walk.

Here is the very positive LA Times review from June 5 2008.